The Return of Gandalf

   (Add a Comment and Rate This)

Reader Comments

   (Add a Comment and Rate This)

... 34 Comments

1. I think it looks great but a little room for improvment.

   Comment by bjzman87 - April 28, 2001 @ 1:17 PM - Rated a 4

2. I think it looks great but a little room for improvment.

   Comment by bjzman87 - April 28, 2001 @ 1:17 PM - Rated a 4

3. Comment by FrodoTook - July 19, 2001 @ 8:52 PM - Rated a 5

4. Comment by FrodoTook - July 19, 2001 @ 8:52 PM - Rated a 5

5. One of the top 10 images ever from LOTR or any book! I would give it a 10 if I could!

   Comment by peterpan - August 1, 2001 @ 2:28 PM - Rated a 5

6. One of the top 10 images ever from LOTR or any book! I would give it a 10 if I could!

   Comment by peterpan - August 1, 2001 @ 2:28 PM - Rated a 5

7. Except for Gandalf's overly - dramatic pose, this is a
   wonderful painting.
   From the 1978 Tolkien Calendar (June).

   Comment by RWeiss - August 4, 2001 @ 7:24 PM - Rated a 4

8. Except for Gandalf's overly - dramatic pose, this is a
   wonderful painting.
   From the 1978 Tolkien Calendar (June).

   Comment by RWeiss - August 4, 2001 @ 7:24 PM - Rated a 4

9. I am very diturbed by the portrayal of Aragorn. He needs to look like a independent person, but to protray him looking like a pirate of the Victorian era is strange to me. I've seen other Hildebrandt pictures that portray the same and it frankly annoys me. Otherwise, great painting.

   Comment by Randolphin - September 2, 2001 @ 8:00 PM

10. I am very diturbed by the portrayal of Aragorn. He needs to look like a independent person, but to protray him looking like a pirate of the Victorian era is strange to me. I've seen other Hildebrandt pictures that portray the same and it frankly annoys me. Otherwise, great painting.

    Comment by Randolphin - September 2, 2001 @ 8:00 PM

11. Comment by arcturus55 - September 27, 2001 @ 6:50 PM - Rated a 4

12. Comment by arcturus55 - September 27, 2001 @ 6:50 PM - Rated a 4

13. ok, what is WITH the HAT??? and wernt elves supposed 2 b like 6 foot or sumthing? they're not pixies u know. but otherwise, its very very good

    Comment by ellee - March 9, 2002 @ 1:47 PM - Rated a 2

14. ok, what is WITH the HAT??? and wernt elves supposed 2 b like 6 foot or sumthing? they're not pixies u know. but otherwise, its very very good

    Comment by ellee - March 9, 2002 @ 1:47 PM - Rated a 2

15. Comment by ellee - March 9, 2002 @ 1:49 PM

16. Comment by ellee - March 9, 2002 @ 1:49 PM

17. you can almost feel the excitement they felt when they saw Gandalf... ALIVE!!

    Comment by legolas_nymph - March 17, 2002 @ 3:15 PM - Rated a 4

18. you can almost feel the excitement they felt when they saw Gandalf... ALIVE!!

    Comment by legolas_nymph - March 17, 2002 @ 3:15 PM - Rated a 4

19. you can almost feel the excitement they felt when they saw Gandalf... ALIVE!!!

    Comment by legolas_nymph - March 17, 2002 @ 3:18 PM

20. you can almost feel the excitement they felt when they saw Gandalf... ALIVE!!!

    Comment by legolas_nymph - March 17, 2002 @ 3:18 PM

21. Ok. That's pretty cool. The only thing I think is wrong is Aragorn looks like one of the Three Musketeers with that hat. But other than that, I like it.

    Comment by Laurel - September 23, 2002 @ 2:33 PM - Rated a 4

22. Ok. That's pretty cool. The only thing I think is wrong is Aragorn looks like one of the Three Musketeers with that hat. But other than that, I like it.

    Comment by Laurel - September 23, 2002 @ 2:33 PM - Rated a 4

23. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

24. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

25. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

26. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

27. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

28. I don't really like the other people, but Gandalf looks AWESOME! I would rate Gandalf a 5 but the rest of the picture I don't really like, so I'm giving it a three.

    Comment by Ithildin-EredRanger - September 24, 2002 @ 10:33 AM - Rated a 3

29. What is with his bow? If he is suposed to be aiming it at gandalf, which I asume he is as that's what he does in the book until he is sure it is Gandalf, it should be drawn back, the bowstring forming a triangle with the bow....NOT LIKE THIS!

    Comment by mekilno1 - September 25, 2002 @ 1:59 AM - Rated a 3

30. What is with his bow? If he is suposed to be aiming it at gandalf, which I asume he is as that's what he does in the book until he is sure it is Gandalf, it should be drawn back, the bowstring forming a triangle with the bow....NOT LIKE THIS!

    Comment by mekilno1 - September 25, 2002 @ 1:59 AM - Rated a 3

31. Comment by EowynEorling - February 21, 2003 @ 12:56 PM - Rated a 5

32. Comment by EowynEorling - February 21, 2003 @ 12:56 PM - Rated a 5

33. its good though

    Comment by leafluv - April 14, 2003 @ 12:13 AM - Rated a 5

34. its good though

    Comment by leafluv - April 14, 2003 @ 12:13 AM - Rated a 5

Leave a Comment